Voices: ‘Is my chemotherapy vegan?’

‘Is my chemotherapy vegan?’ | B.J. Rimel, MD

BJ Rimel_headshot 2“Is my chemotherapy vegan?”

Despite my 12 years of post-graduate training, I was completely floored by this question.  To be honest, my initial response was not what it could have been.

“I have no earthly idea,” I said, in my best doctor voice.  I left the clinic feeling completely incredulous that anyone with a life-threatening cancer would care if their chemo was in any way associated with animal products.  As a new attending, I initially felt righteous that I had not given in to a long discussion about non-evidence based treatments, and instead steered our conversation back to symptom management, dosing schedule and a review of the side effects she was likely to experience.

My patient left the clinic and decided not to return to me for care.  When I heard she had transferred her care to another physician I felt that there was probably something important I could learn from this experience. So, I did a bit of reading.  As it turns out, there are lots of reasons to ask about vegan products and not all of them are grounded in nuts and berries.

The term vegan was first coined in 1944 by Donald Watson.  The main tenant of the diet is the complete avoidance of animal products.  Followers of the vegan diet eat no meat, no fish, no dairy, no eggs, no honey and no products that are processed with the use of an animal product.  However, for some veganism is also a lifestyle choice, and the avoidance of eating, wearing or using animal products is a manifestation of the goal of non-violence.  This principle is called ahimsa in Sanskrit and the word literally means “to do no harm.”

“Do no harm” sounded eerily familiar to me.  I clearly remember sitting in Duke Chapel listening to the dean recite the Hippocratic Oath on a very humid day in 2003.  Reflecting on that experience, I would change how I responded to this patient.  I should have asked why it was important to her.  Maybe it would not have made any difference.  Perhaps she was only asking because she thought that a vegan diet would cure her cancer, but perhaps we would have found some common ground in our lifestyle choices to “do no harm.”

One thought on “Voices: ‘Is my chemotherapy vegan?’

  1. As a 15 year vegan who has endured some fairly rare (and serious) medical conditions myself, I can safely say that anyone who is concerned with the ethics of their chemo drugs over saving their own life is someone who is in need of a great deal of therapy. I’m sorry, but there’s no way to say it – when preserving the perceived ethics of a movement override one’s own health and safety concerns, it’s mental illness and brainwashing that takes them to this point. The fact that they’d honestly expect you to know off-the-cuff if there might have been animal testing or any animal-based ingredients in the chemo drugs recommended just goes to show the shallowness of far too many vegans whose lives are consumed by the lunacy of believing it’s noble to sacrifice one’s self so in theory, perhaps one lab rat that may or may not even exist might not have succumbed to some sort of cruelty. Unfortunately, many vegans believe that self-sacrifice in such a manner is actually noble, when in reality, it’s foolishness.

    There’s a time to be compassionate toward the questions of others who are frightened of what will happen, and there are times to say “Your life and future hangs in the balance of your decision, and if you choose to martyr yourself, people will not be singing hymns in your honor for your sacrifice”. I had to make decisions that went against my ethics, and they were the RIGHT decisions to make.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *